Leaving Group Order in substitution reaction

Leaving Group Order

For common organic chemistry leaving groups, the order of leaving-group ability is:

I⁻ > Br⁻ > Cl⁻ > F⁻

So:

RI > RBr > RCl > RF
for SN1/SN2 reactions, generally.

Common leaving groups — good → poor

OTf⁻ > OTs⁻ ≈ OMs⁻ > I⁻ > Br⁻ > Cl⁻ > OAc> F⁻>OH–> NH2->H-

  • OTf = triflate
  • OTs = tosylate
  • OMs = mesylate

Important trick

“The weaker the base, the better the leaving group.”

For halide ions, basicity increases:

F⁻ > Cl⁻ > Br⁻ > I⁻

Therefore leaving-group ability is the reverse:

I⁻ > Br⁻ > Cl⁻ > F⁻.

OTf = triflate

Why does –SO₃H disappear?

The key point is that –SO₃H acts as a temporary blocking group.

Step 1: Desulphonation

The starting compound is p-hydroxybenzenesulphonic acid:

On treatment with aqueous bromine, the strongly activating –OH group directs bromination to the ortho and para positions.

But the para position is occupied by –SO₃H.

Step 2: Bromination

Therefore, Br enters the two ortho positions:

The final product is:2,4,6-Tribromophenol (white precipitate)\boxed{\text{2,4,6-Tribromophenol (white precipitate)}}

Why does –SO₃H disappear?

Under the aqueous bromination conditions, desulphonation occurs, replacing SO3H by H. This allows bromination at the para position as well.

So the overall idea is:Blocking group removed + bromination at all available o/p positions\boxed{\text{Blocking group removed + bromination at all available o/p positions}}

Hence 3 Br atoms finally occupy the 2, 4 and 6 positions of phenol.

Benzophenone (C6H5)2CO generally does NOT react readily with NaHSO₃ why?

Benzophenone is even more hindered than acetophenone:(C6H5)2C=O(C_6H_5)_2C=O

Two effects make HSO3−HSO_3^- addition difficult:

  1. Very high steric hindrance
    The carbonyl carbon is surrounded by two phenyl groups, so HSO3−HSO_3^- cannot easily attack it.
  2. Resonance/conjugation
    The carbonyl group is conjugated with both benzene rings, reducing the electrophilic character of the carbonyl carbon.

Reactivity comparison

Aldehydes>acetophenone>benzophenone\boxed{\text{Aldehydes} > \text{acetophenone} > \text{benzophenone}}

So for the NaHSO₃ addition test:

  • Aldehydes → generally react readily ✅
  • Acetophenone → poor/slow reaction
  • Benzophenone → generally does not react under usual conditions ❌

Key JEE/NEET fact: Benzophenone is a classic example of a ketone that does not form the usual sodium bisulfite addition compound readily because of steric hindrance + resonance stabilization.

Which reaction proceeds fastest with NaI in DMSO?

The answer is (B) benzyl chloride, C₆H₅–CH₂Cl.

The reagent is NaI in DMSO, which strongly favors an SN2 reaction.

Step 1: Compare the substrates

  • A: tertiary alkyl chloride → highly hindered ❌
  • B: benzyl chloride, C₆H₅–CH₂Cl → primary benzylic chloride ✅
  • C: chlorobenzene, C₆H₅–Cl → aryl chloride, SN2 doesn’t occur ❌
  • D: cyclohexylmethyl chloride → primary, but not benzylic

Step 2: Why is B exceptionally fast?

In benzyl chloride:

C₆H₅–CH₂–Cl

The carbon attacked by I⁻ is the CH₂ next to the benzene ring.

During SN2, the transition state has some electron deficiency at this carbon. The benzene ring can stabilize this transition state by resonance.

So:

benzyl chloride → very fast SN2

Also, DMSO is a polar aprotic solvent, which makes I⁻ a strong nucleophile and favors SN2.

Important order to remember

For SN2 reactivity:

benzyl/allyl halide > primary > secondary >> tertiary

And aryl/vinyl halides do not normally undergo SN2.

An electron-withdrawing group adjacent to the carbon undergoing SN2 can strongly accelerate SN2 reaction.

Answer: (A)

III<I<II<IV\boxed{\text{III} < \text{I} < \text{II} < \text{IV}}

Reason:

  • III → more steric hindrance → slowest SN2S_N2
  • I → secondary alkyl chloride
  • II → secondary alkyl bromide; Br⁻ is a better leaving group than Cl⁻
  • IV → α\alpha-bromoketone; carbonyl group strongly activates the SN2S_N2 reaction → fastest

Correct option: (A) III < I < II < I

V is highest because it is an α-bromo ketone:CH3CO−CH(Br)−CH2CH3\mathrm{CH_3CO-CH(Br)-CH_2CH_3}

The key effect is the carbonyl group (C=O)

Why does C=OC=O increase SN2S_N2 rate?

The carbonyl group has a strong −I (electron-withdrawing) effect:C=O→CH(Br)\mathrm{C=O \rightarrow CH(Br)}

It pulls electron density away from the carbon bearing Br, making that carbon more electrophilic.

Iodoform Test — JEE/NEET Concept

Iodoform test is used to identify compounds containing:CH3CO−\boxed{CH_3CO-}

or compounds that can be oxidised to a methyl ketone.

1. Reagent

I2+NaOH\boxed{I_2 + NaOH}

Positive test: formation of a yellow precipitate of iodoformCHI3=yellow precipitate\boxed{CHI_3 = \text{yellow precipitate}}


2. Main compounds giving the test

A. Methyl ketones

General structure:R−CO−CH3\boxed{R-CO-CH_3}

Example:CH3COCH3→I2/NaOHCHI3↓CH_3COCH_3 \xrightarrow{I_2/NaOH} CHI_3\downarrow

So acetone gives iodoform test.


B. Ethanol

Ethanol is oxidised to acetaldehyde, which gives the test:CH3CH2OH→CH3CHO→CHI3CH_3CH_2OH \rightarrow CH_3CHO \rightarrow CHI_3

Therefore:CH3CH2OH gives iodoform test\boxed{CH_3CH_2OH \text{ gives iodoform test}}


C. Secondary alcohols of type

CH3−CH(OH)−R\boxed{CH_3-CH(OH)-R}

These are oxidised to:CH3−CO−RCH_3-CO-R

which is a methyl ketone.

Example:CH3CH(OH)CH3CH_3CH(OH)CH_3

Propan-2-ol → positive.


3. Important examples

CompoundIodoform test
CH3COCH3CH_3COCH_3✅
CH3COCH2CH3CH_3COCH_2CH_3✅
CH3CHOCH_3CHO✅
CH3CH2OHCH_3CH_2OH✅
CH3CH(OH)CH3CH_3CH(OH)CH_3✅
CH3CH(OH)C2H5CH_3CH(OH)C_2H_5✅
CH3CH2CH2OHCH_3CH_2CH_2OH❌
CH3COOHCH_3COOH❌

JEE/NEET shortcut

Look for:CH3CO−\boxed{CH_3CO-}

ORCH3CH(OH)−\boxed{CH_3CH(OH)-}

If either is present → Iodoform test is generally positive.

Special exception

Acetaldehyde (CH3CHO) gives the iodoform test even though it is not a methyl ketone.CH3CHO→CHI3↓\boxed{CH_3CHO \rightarrow CHI_3\downarrow}

Fehling’s Test — JEE/NEET Concept

Fehling’s test is mainly used to detect aliphatic aldehydes.

1. Fehling’s reagent

It consists of two solutions:

  • Fehling A: CuSO4CuSO_4 solution
  • Fehling B: alkaline sodium potassium tartrate (Rochelle salt) + NaOH

They are mixed freshly before the test.


2. Reaction with aldehyde

For an aliphatic aldehyde:RCHO+2Cu2++5OH−→RCOO−+Cu2O↓+3H2O\boxed{RCHO + 2Cu^{2+} + 5OH^- \rightarrow RCOO^- + Cu_2O\downarrow + 3H_2O}

Observation:Blue solution→brick-red Cu2O precipitate\boxed{\text{Blue solution} \rightarrow \text{brick-red }Cu_2O\text{ precipitate}}

Aldehyde is oxidised → carboxylate
Cu2+Cu^{2+} is reduced → Cu2OCu_2O


3. Which compounds give Fehling’s test?

CompoundFehling test
Aliphatic aldehyde✅ Positive
Formaldehyde, HCHO✅ Positive
Acetaldehyde, CH₃CHO✅ Positive
Aromatic aldehyde, C₆H₅CHO❌ Generally negative
Ketones❌ Negative
Formic acid/formates✅ Can reduce Cu²⁺
Reducing sugars✅ Positive

Most important distinction

Aliphatic aldehyde → Fehling positive\boxed{\text{Aliphatic aldehyde → Fehling positive}}Aromatic aldehyde → Fehling generally negative\boxed{\text{Aromatic aldehyde → Fehling generally negative}}

But both can give Tollens’ test:RCHO → Tollens positive\boxed{\text{RCHO → Tollens positive}}RCHO (aliphatic) → Fehling positive\boxed{\text{RCHO (aliphatic) → Fehling positive}}ArCHO → Fehling generally negative\boxed{\text{ArCHO → Fehling generally negative}}

JEE/NEET trap

Benzaldehyde (C6H5CHO)

  • Tollens → ✅ Silver mirror
  • Fehling → ❌ No brick-red precipitate

Acetaldehyde (CH3CHO)

  • Tollens → ✅
  • Fehling → ✅

Memory trick:
“Fehling likes aliphatic aldehydes, not aromatic aldehydes.”

Tollens’ Test — JEE/NEET Concept

Tollens’ reagent = ammoniacal AgNO₃

It contains the complex ion:[Ag(NH3)2]+\boxed{[Ag(NH_3)_2]^+}

It is mainly used to identify aldehydes.

1. Basic reaction

For an aldehyde:RCHO+2[Ag(NH3)2]++3OH−→RCOO−+2Ag↓+4NH3+2H2ORCHO + 2[Ag(NH_3)_2]^+ + 3OH^- \rightarrow RCOO^- + 2Ag\downarrow +4NH_3+2H_2O

Observation: Silver mirror is formed.

Aldehyde → oxidised to carboxylate
Ag⁺ → reduced to metallic Ag


2. Which compounds give Tollens’ test?

CompoundTollens’ test
Aldehyde, R–CHO✅ Positive
Formic acid, HCOOH✅ Positive
Formate ion, HCOO⁻✅ Positive
α-hydroxy aldehyde✅ Positive
Reducing sugars✅ Positive
Ketones, R–CO–R❌ Usually negative
Most carboxylic acids❌ Negative
Esters❌ Negative

3. Important JEE trick

Formic acid is an exception.HCOOH→TollensCO2+Ag\boxed{HCOOH \xrightarrow{\text{Tollens}} CO_2 + Ag}

Because formic acid can be oxidised to CO2CO_2, it reduces Ag⁺.

So:Aldehydes + HCOOH + formates → Tollens positive\boxed{\text{Aldehydes + HCOOH + formates → Tollens positive}}


4. Why ketones generally don’t react?

Ketones do not readily oxidise under the mild conditions of Tollens’ reagent.R−CO−R′→TollensNo reactionR-CO-R’ \quad \xrightarrow{\text{Tollens}} \quad \text{No reaction}

But beware: some compounds containing a ketone group can give a positive test if they can tautomerise/rearrange to an aldehyde-type reducing species.


5. Glucose gives Tollens’ test

Glucose predominantly exists in cyclic form, but it can establish equilibrium with its open-chain aldehyde form:Glucose⇌open-chain glucose\text{Glucose} \rightleftharpoons \text{open-chain glucose}

The open-chain form reduces Tollens’ reagent.

Hence:Glucose → positive Tollens’ test\boxed{\text{Glucose → positive Tollens’ test}}


6. Common JEE/NEET comparison

Tollens’ test → Aldehyde\boxed{\text{Tollens’ test → Aldehyde}}Fehling’s test → Aliphatic aldehydes mainly\boxed{\text{Fehling’s test → Aliphatic aldehydes mainly}}Iodoform test → CH3CO− or CH3CH(OH)−\boxed{\text{Iodoform test → } CH_3CO- \text{ or } CH_3CH(OH)-}

One-line memory

“Tollens = Silver mirror = Aldehyde oxidation.”

Alpha-Particle Scattering Experiment Physics 12 cbse chapter atoms

Alpha-Particle Scattering Experiment

Scientists: H. Geiger and E. Marsden, under Rutherford
Year: 1911
Source: Radioactive 83214Bi^{214}_{83}\mathrm{Bi}
Particles: α\alpha-particles of energy 5.5 MeV
Target: Thin gold foil
Gold foil thickness: 2.1×10−7 m2.1\times10^{-7}\,\text{m}

Why gold foil was used?

Gold can be beaten into an extremely thin foil, so α-particles can pass through it.

Observation

  1. Most α-particles passed straight through the foil.
    • Therefore, most of the atom is empty space.
  2. Very few α-particles were deflected through small angles.
    • Only about 0.14% scattered by more than 1∘1^\circ.
  3. About 1 in 8000 α-particles was deflected through an angle greater than 90∘90^\circ.
  4. A very small number of α-particles were scattered backwards.

Rutherford’s Conclusions

1. Most of the atom is empty space

Since most α-particles passed through without deflection, the atom must contain a large amount of empty space.

2. Positive charge is concentrated

Large deflections require a strong repulsive force.

Therefore, the positive charge of the atom must be concentrated in a very small region at the centre.

This region is called the nucleus.

3. Most of the mass is in the nucleus

The nucleus contains:

  • Entire positive charge
  • Almost entire mass of the atom

4. Nucleus is extremely small

Size of nucleus:10−15 m to 10−14 m\boxed{10^{-15}\text{ m to }10^{-14}\text{ m}}

Size of atom:10−10 m\boxed{10^{-10}\text{ m}}

Therefore, the nucleus is extremely small compared with the atom.

5. Electrons revolve around nucleus

Electrons are present at a considerable distance from the nucleus and move around it, similar to planets revolving around the Sun.


Rutherford Nuclear Model

According to Rutherford:Atom=tiny positive nucleus+electrons around it\boxed{\text{Atom}=\text{tiny positive nucleus}+\text{electrons around it}}

Main points

  • Nucleus is at the centre of the atom.
  • Nucleus is positively charged.
  • Almost the entire mass of the atom is concentrated in the nucleus.
  • Electrons revolve around the nucleus.
  • Most of the atom is empty space.
  • Atomic electrons are very light and therefore do not appreciably affect α-particle scattering.

Coulomb Force in α-Particle Scattering

An α-particle has charge:q1=+2eq_1=+2e

Gold nucleus has charge:q2=+Zeq_2=+Ze

For gold:Z=79Z=79

Using Coulomb’s law:F=14πε0(2e)(Ze)r2F=\frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} \frac{(2e)(Ze)}{r^2}

Therefore,F=14πε02Ze2r2\boxed{F=\frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\frac{2Ze^2}{r^2}}

This force is repulsive because both α-particle and gold nucleus are positively charged.

Important assumption

The gold nucleus is about 50 times heavier than an α-particle, so the nucleus can be considered stationary during scattering.

Also, because the gold foil is very thin, an α-particle is assumed to undergo not more than one scattering.

Most important exam line

Most particles pass straight⇒atom mostly empty space\boxed{\text{Most particles pass straight} \Rightarrow \text{atom mostly empty space}}Few particles deflect strongly⇒small, dense, positively charged nucleus\boxed{\text{Few particles deflect strongly} \Rightarrow \text{small, dense, positively charged nucleus}}