Tollens’ Test — JEE/NEET Concept

Tollens’ reagent = ammoniacal AgNO₃

It contains the complex ion:[Ag(NH3)2]+\boxed{[Ag(NH_3)_2]^+}

It is mainly used to identify aldehydes.

1. Basic reaction

For an aldehyde:RCHO+2[Ag(NH3)2]++3OHRCOO+2Ag+4NH3+2H2ORCHO + 2[Ag(NH_3)_2]^+ + 3OH^- \rightarrow RCOO^- + 2Ag\downarrow +4NH_3+2H_2O

Observation: Silver mirror is formed.

Aldehyde → oxidised to carboxylate
Ag⁺ → reduced to metallic Ag


2. Which compounds give Tollens’ test?

CompoundTollens’ test
Aldehyde, R–CHO✅ Positive
Formic acid, HCOOH✅ Positive
Formate ion, HCOO⁻✅ Positive
α-hydroxy aldehyde✅ Positive
Reducing sugars✅ Positive
Ketones, R–CO–R❌ Usually negative
Most carboxylic acids❌ Negative
Esters❌ Negative

3. Important JEE trick

Formic acid is an exception.HCOOHTollensCO2+Ag\boxed{HCOOH \xrightarrow{\text{Tollens}} CO_2 + Ag}

Because formic acid can be oxidised to CO2CO_2, it reduces Ag⁺.

So:Aldehydes + HCOOH + formates → Tollens positive\boxed{\text{Aldehydes + HCOOH + formates → Tollens positive}}


4. Why ketones generally don’t react?

Ketones do not readily oxidise under the mild conditions of Tollens’ reagent.RCORTollensNo reactionR-CO-R’ \quad \xrightarrow{\text{Tollens}} \quad \text{No reaction}

But beware: some compounds containing a ketone group can give a positive test if they can tautomerise/rearrange to an aldehyde-type reducing species.


5. Glucose gives Tollens’ test

Glucose predominantly exists in cyclic form, but it can establish equilibrium with its open-chain aldehyde form:Glucoseopen-chain glucose\text{Glucose} \rightleftharpoons \text{open-chain glucose}

The open-chain form reduces Tollens’ reagent.

Hence:Glucose → positive Tollens’ test\boxed{\text{Glucose → positive Tollens’ test}}


6. Common JEE/NEET comparison

Tollens’ test → Aldehyde\boxed{\text{Tollens’ test → Aldehyde}}Fehling’s test → Aliphatic aldehydes mainly\boxed{\text{Fehling’s test → Aliphatic aldehydes mainly}}Iodoform test → CH3CO or CH3CH(OH)\boxed{\text{Iodoform test → } CH_3CO- \text{ or } CH_3CH(OH)-}

One-line memory

“Tollens = Silver mirror = Aldehyde oxidation.”

Leave a comment